"The only reason Trustee Anderson has helped build three treatment plants, is because we keep building new homes." That line comes from the minutes of the Holmen Village Board meeting on October 9, 2025. They summarize Village Administrator Heinig's reasons for the largest update to the village's impact fees in a decade.
That same night the board did something that matters to anyone pricing a new home in Holmen. It adopted a full impact fee of $20,345 for each new residential unit. Then it voted to collect only about a quarter of that, $5,276 per unit, starting January 1, 2026. Both numbers are in force. The higher one sits in the village code, and the lower one is what the board chose to charge.
For a buyer comparing a new build with an existing home, the gap between those figures is part of the price. It is a gap the village can change every year.
The full schedule is about five times the old one
Impact fees are one-time charges on new development. They help pay for the sewer, water, parks, and public safety facilities that growth requires. Holmen's ordinance lists them by category. Here is the 2025 rate in each category next to the full rate the board adopted in Ordinance 5-2025.
| Category, per residential unit | 2025 rate | Full adopted rate |
|---|---|---|
| Highways and transportation | $413 | $2,893 |
| Sewage collection and treatment | $1,587 | $8,490 |
| Water pumping, storage and distribution | $877 | $4,282 |
| Parks and playgrounds | $717 | $2,795 |
| Fire protection and emergency medical | $0 | $658 |
| Law enforcement | $160 | $1,000 |
| Public library | $295 | $227 |
| Total | $4,049 | $20,345 |
The $5,276 charge in effect for 2026 is $1,227 more than the old $4,049. It is still about $15,000 below what the village's own Public Facilities Needs Assessment supports. The minutes say the board adopted the study and fee structure in full on purpose, "allowing the Village flexibility to modify rates in the future should increases be necessary." The motion passed 7-0.
One practical caution: the village's published 2026 fee schedule shows the full component rates, while the board minutes record the $5,276 decision. Anyone budgeting a build should confirm with the Village of Holmen which figure is being invoiced on their permit.
What the village says the full number pays for
The full rate is not an arbitrary ceiling. Heinig told the board that infrastructure costs had more than doubled in ten years and gave figures from Holmen's own projects.
- Three new parks in three new residential areas cost $4.5 million, which the minutes say was twice the forecast from ten years earlier.
- Sanitary sewer lift stations that cost about $150,000 a decade ago now cost about $750,000. The village built three in the 18 months before the meeting, all to serve new growth.
- A $4 million lift station and force main was planned for the following year to serve Liberty Addition and the North Village.
- A new well and reservoir in the North Village cost $7.5 million.
- The sewer treatment plant cost $13 million.
- A new fire station is projected at $14 million.
Heinig called charging the full rate "overly excessive" and still called the study accurate. Trustee Doug Jorstad said the proposed fees were "far too high" to implement, and added that the village "cannot put the lone burden" of growth on existing residents. Both positions shaped the result. The board kept the higher number legally in place and set the charge well below it.
Two members of the La Crosse Area Builders Association spoke at the public hearing. Executive Officer Tena Bailey opposed the study rates. She said the added costs would be passed on to consumers and could affect whether the average worker can afford a median-priced new home. Kraig Lassig, also a member, called the reduced fee reasonable and fair given the village's investments in sewer, water, and lift stations.
The fee runs on an annual clock, and this is the window
The rate does not stay put by default. Chapter 76 of the Holmen code requires the village to review its development potential, capital improvements plan, and impact fees every year as part of the capital budget process. The review can account for inflation, revised cost estimates, and changes in facility needs. Any changes "shall be recommended for adoption prior to December 1 of each year and shall be effective on January 1."
The 2027 cycle is underway now.
- September 28, 2026. A special board meeting covered the draft 2027 budget and a possible referral to a public hearing.
- October 8, 2026. The posted board agenda lists Finance and Personnel business. It does not list an impact fee change.
- November 12, 2026, 6:30 p.m. This is the date the September 28 agenda proposed for a public hearing on the 2027 budget.
- Before December 1. This is the code's deadline to recommend any fee change for January 1, 2027.
None of the board agendas or minutes posted from June through early October 2026 lists a proposed impact fee change. As of today, nothing on the record points to a 2027 increase. The structure the board created still leaves room for one in any year, and this review season is when that question gets settled.
Where the new units are coming from
This matters because Holmen has a lot of new construction moving through approvals, and each new unit is subject to the fee.
Cole Addition Ten. The village approved a development agreement on March 12, 2026, and described this phase as Elmwood Partners' final phase of a 15-year project. The board conditionally approved its improvements and plat on August 13, 2026.
Herb & Iris Addition. Its preliminary plat was approved in April 2025. Conditional approval of its improvements and plat appeared on the September 10, 2026 board agenda.
S&J Farms La Crosse LLC. In April 2025 the board approved rezoning 41.23 acres east of Hwy. 53 and north of Old County NA from agricultural to a mix of R-1 single-family, R-6 zero-lot-line, and R-4 two-family zoning.
Prestige Heights Apartments. These are three 38-unit buildings, 114 units total, at Spakenburg Road and Staphorst Lane. The board approved the PUD on July 9, 2026.
1606 Flat Road. Wieser Brothers proposed a four-unit townhouse condo here, which received a multifamily rezoning recommendation and site plan approval on March 31, 2026.
Rosewood Luxury Apartments. This proposal from Birdd Construction covers about 10 acres at Viking Avenue and Rivers Drive, east of Festival Foods. It was on the August and September 2026 agendas, and the posted materials do not show final approval.
The board also approved three annexations on July 9, 2026. One is Mark Hein's 45.67 acres south of Old Hwy. 93 and west of USH 53, described as land for possible future development. Beyond new development, Holmen's Main Street reconstruction is planned to start in spring 2027 and includes sanitary sewer and water main replacement. The project overview lists infrastructure that accommodates future growth of the community among its goals.
How this changes the new versus resale comparison
A resale home in Holmen was permitted under whatever fee applied when it was built. A buyer purchasing it today pays no new impact fee. A new home is charged per unit under the current rate, and Bailey told the board those costs end up in the buyer's price.
At the 2026 rate, that fee is a modest part of a new home's cost. News 8 quoted the La Crosse Area REALTORS Association president estimating new Holmen homes at $400,000 to $500,000. The same report described entry-level inventory as scarce, with older homes freed up by move-up buyers reaching the market slowly.
The broader market is giving buyers a bit more time. Wisconsin REALTORS Association data for La Crosse County for August 2026 shows a median sale price of $330,000, up 6.3% from $310,300 in August 2025. Sales dipped from 133 to 129, average days on market rose from 57 to 70, and inventory rose to 3.7 months. These are countywide figures, not Holmen-only figures.
Together, these facts frame the choice. Resale buyers in La Crosse County have more time to negotiate than a year ago. New-construction buyers in Holmen face a growing pipeline and a per-unit village fee that the board currently sets well below its calculated cost and reviews every fall. If you are signing a build contract that will be permitted after January 1, ask your builder which year's fee schedule their pricing assumes and who absorbs any change.
A few direct questions
Does the impact fee apply when I buy an existing Holmen home? The fee is charged per new housing unit at the point of development, according to the board's motion. A buyer purchasing an existing home is not paying a new charge under Ordinance 5-2025.
Is Holmen raising the fee for 2027? No posted agenda through October 8, 2026 lists a change. The code requires any change to be recommended before December 1 and to take effect January 1, so the outcome for 2027 will be known by year's end.
Where can I read the actual fee table? The full schedule is in Chapter 76 of the Holmen code, section 76-12, on the Village of Holmen website. The October 9, 2025 decision to collect $5,276 is in the board minutes.
Deciding between a new build in Cole Addition and a resale home a few streets over comes down to more than list price. Favre & Co. tracks Holmen's board agendas, fee schedules, and closed sales so you can compare the full cost of each option before you commit. If you already own in Holmen and are curious how your home compares with new construction nearby, start with "What's My Home Worth?"
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.