Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Covered entry of a gray-sided home with brown brick, a charcoal door, white-framed window and concrete steps beside an autumn hydrangea.

La Crosse's Property Tax Rate Dropped. So Why Didn't the Bills?

October 15, 2026

Suppose you buy a home in the City of La Crosse this fall. At closing, your property taxes will almost certainly be prorated from the bill the seller paid for 2025. The bill you will actually pay arrives in December 2026, and the city is still writing its budget. Its Board of Estimates took up the 2027 preliminary budget this week. So the tax figure on a listing describes the past, and the figure that matters to you is still being set.

That gap matters more in La Crosse than in most places right now. In its last budget cycle the city's tax rate dropped by about 13%, and the total amount of property tax on those bills went up. Once you see how both happened at once, you can stop comparing communities by mill rate and start comparing them by a number that holds up.

The rate fell because the denominator grew

A mill rate is a division problem. In the city's 2026 Operating Budget, the formula is printed outright: the levy divided by total assessed value. Raise the bottom number faster than the top one and the rate falls, even if every taxing body collects more money.

That is what the 2025 revaluation did. Here are the city's own figures for the two most recent tax years:

Tax year 2024 Tax year 2025
Total mill rate on annual tax bills $21.08 per $1,000 $18.33 per $1,000
Total assessed value $4,675,879,900 $5,728,214,900
Change in assessed value +22.51%
State-certified equalized value $5,638,471,900 $5,970,494,100
Change in equalized value +5.89%
Assessed value as a share of equalized 82.93% 95.94%

The key row is the gap between assessed and equalized value. Equalized value is the state's own estimate of what all the taxable property in a community is worth on the market. That rose under 6%. Assessed value rose more than 22% because the assessments themselves were brought up to market. Before the revaluation, La Crosse assessed property at about 83% of market value. After it, the figure was about 96%.

Meanwhile the money being raised went up. According to the same budget table, the city's levy, including tax increment districts, rose 2.77% to $48.8 million. The La Crosse School District's levy on city property rose 10.93% to $39.2 million. We added up every levy in that table and subtracted the state school credit. By our math, total tax on city bills came to about $104.6 million for tax year 2025, up from about $98.2 million the year before. That is an increase of roughly 6.5%, under a rate that fell 13%.

Measured against market value, the burden barely moved. By the same math, it was about $17.40 per $1,000 of equalized value in 2024 and about $17.50 in 2025. In other words, the lower rate mostly reflects the change in how property is measured. The cost of owning property in the city stayed close to where it was.

To make that concrete, take a hypothetical home worth $300,000 on the market in both years. At an 83% assessment level and $21.08 per $1,000, its bill works out to roughly $5,245. At a 96% level and $18.33, it works out to roughly $5,275. The rate fell about 13% and this home's bill went up slightly. Real parcels were revalued one at a time, so actual bills moved by different amounts.

Why the state made the city do it

Speaking to WXOW after the new notices went out, District 7 council member Gary Padesky said: "The number one question is why, why so soon. The last one was just a few years back, but this one comes by direction of the state." WXOW noted the previous citywide revaluation was in 2022.

The rule behind that comment appears in the Wisconsin Department of Revenue's 2026 Property Assessment Process Guide. At least once every five years, each major class of property has to be assessed within 10% of full value in the same year. A community that stays out of compliance gets a DOR notice after four years and a second one after five. After six years, the state orders a supervised assessment. An 82.9% assessment level is well outside that 10% band.

The same guide explains what a revaluation does to tax bills. If the levy stays the same, properties that were paying less than their share pay more, and properties that were paying more than their share pay less. When total assessed value rises with an unchanged levy, the rate falls. A revaluation moves the tax burden between properties. Whether bills rise overall depends on the levies.

The comparison that holds up across town lines

This affects anyone weighing La Crosse against Onalaska or Holmen. Nominal mill rates are only comparable when communities assess at similar levels, so DOR publishes a full-value rate for every municipality. Its 2025 Town, Village and City Taxes report calls that rate the better tool for comparing tax districts, because every district's property is valued on the same basis. The "effective" version subtracts the state school levy credit.

Taxes levied 2025, collected 2026 Assessment level Gross full-value rate Effective full-value rate
City of La Crosse 0.96 $18.93 per $1,000 $17.59 per $1,000
City of Onalaska 0.99 $15.16 per $1,000 $13.61 per $1,000
Village of Holmen 0.97 $15.58 per $1,000 $14.52 per $1,000

All three communities now assess close to market, so the rate on a tax bill and the full-value rate tell roughly the same story. That was not true in 2024, when a La Crosse bill rate reflected property assessed at about 83% of value. Comparing it to a community assessing near 100% would have made La Crosse look more expensive than it was.

These are municipal averages, and one community can have several rates depending on school district. La Crosse County's 2025 rate sheet lists the City of La Crosse at $18.33 per $1,000 in the La Crosse School District and $18.80 in the Onalaska School District. Holmen village is listed at $15.22. Onalaska city is listed at $13.87 in the Onalaska School District and $12.75 in the Holmen School District. To compare two specific homes, check the rate for each parcel.

Where the extra levy came from

Most of the increase on La Crosse bills came from the school line. The district's 2025-26 budget book shows its gross levy up 11.05%. Debt service rose from $1.17 million to $4.31 million, while the operating referendum stayed flat at $10.75 million. That debt service follows from the $53.5 million capital referendum voters approved in November 2024, which pays for a new elementary school and an addition at State Road Elementary. The April 2023 operating referendum authorizes $10.75 million a year through 2028-29.

The La Crosse Tribune reported that the district's mill rate rose $0.36 rather than the $0.44 that had been projected. The city's budget table shows the school rate on La Crosse bills falling, from 7.64 mills to 6.92. Both figures can be accurate. The district rate covers its whole territory, while the city table applies the school levy to La Crosse's newly revalued assessments. The levy rose, and the larger assessed base absorbed the rate increase.

What is being decided this month

Your December 2026 bill depends on three things that are still moving:

  1. Assessed values. The city says it is doing an interim revaluation for the 2026 assessment year. Notices were expected in April, Open Book ran April 29 through May 6, and the Board of Review first met May 14. The city has not published how much values changed or which properties were covered.
  2. The city levy. The 2027 preliminary budget packet prepared for the October 12 Board of Estimates meeting projects total assessed value for tax year 2026 at $5,803,642,200. That is up 1.32%. The packet's levy-limit worksheet credits net new construction with an adjustment of just 0.381%. Scenario 1 holds the city's portion of the bill at $852.56 per $100,000 of assessed value. Scenario 2 raises it 1.53%, to $865.62. Both scenarios exceed the levy limit, and the packet says there is room under unused debt levy limits. These are proposals. The city's online meeting listing dates the session October 13. Last year's budget was adopted November 17.
  3. Everyone else's levy. The city packet covers only the city's share. The school district, La Crosse County and Western Technical College levies, along with the state credit, make up the rest of the bill and are not in it.

How the closing paperwork handles the gap

Wisconsin's standard offer has a built-in answer for the year when the bill doesn't exist yet. According to the Wisconsin REALTORS Association Legal Hotline, the WB-11 Residential Offer to Purchase lists four proration options. If no box is checked, taxes are prorated on the preceding year's net general taxes, or on the current year's if they are available. A separate box lets buyer and seller agree to re-prorate later against the actual bill for the year of closing. That creates an obligation between the parties after closing, not for the agents.

For a La Crosse closing in October or November 2026, the default proration uses a 2025 bill that already reflects the full revaluation. The re-proration box is how a contract accounts for whatever the interim revaluation and the 2027 budget add to the December 2026 bill.

A few direct questions

Did my La Crosse tax bill go down after the revaluation? It depends on the property. DOR's guidance says a revaluation moves the burden toward properties that had been under-assessed and away from those that had been over-assessed. With total levies up about 6.5% in tax year 2025, the overall amount on city bills went up.

Is a lower La Crosse mill rate a sign the city got cheaper? No. The rate fell because assessed values rose about 22.51% after the 2025 revaluation. Measured against market value, the burden stayed close to where it had been.

Which number should I use to compare La Crosse, Onalaska and Holmen? DOR's full-value effective rate is designed for comparisons between communities. For tax year 2025 it was $17.59 per $1,000 in La Crosse, $13.61 in Onalaska and $14.52 in Holmen. The county rate sheet then gives the actual rate for each school district.

If you're comparing homes across La Crosse, Onalaska and Holmen, the tax line on a listing is only a starting point. At Favre & Co., we pull the parcel's actual rate, its last bill and the proration terms before you write an offer. If you own a La Crosse home and want to know how a buyer will look at its taxes along with its price, start with What's My Home Worth?

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Follow Us On Instagram