The former La Crosse County Farm covers about 115 acres on the east side of West Salem. Lake Neshonoc is to the north, Garland Street and the Lakeview Business Park are to the south, the village boundary is to the east, and the school campus and Mark Street are to the west. About 96 of those acres can be built on. In March 2026, a Stantec presentation reported by WIZM said the county land near the lake could hold 600 to 1,100 homes over 10 to 20 years.
That is the biggest block of future housing in the West Salem area. The county and the village want it to serve the price range the region is shortest on. County and village records put its housing years away, though, and the October sales numbers show that this same price range is where homes sell fastest today. A buyer looking at West Salem this winter is buying in that gap.
The site was planned for the middle of the market
In 2026, La Crosse County and the Village of West Salem put out a Request for Information asking development teams for interest in a mixed-use residential project on the County Farm. The document asks for attainable, workforce, affordable and "missing middle" housing, built in phases with public input.
The reasoning comes from a regional housing study the county commissioned in 2025, which is attached to the RFI. The study projects 2,448 new households in the Greater La Crosse Area between 2025 and 2035. It found a significant shortage of single-family homes priced between $200,000 and $300,000. It also found that homes priced up to $400,000 sell quickly, and that even high-income households compete for homes under $350,000. The study points to a shortage of two- and three-bedroom units for both owners and renters. It also cites low turnover, driven by long tenure and an aging population.
The district's residential timeline moved to 2030
Responses to the RFI were due August 7, 2026. The county described them as input for decisions on possible next steps, such as a formal request for proposals and a development agreement. The RFI's tentative timeline puts master-developer selection, zoning and subdivision approvals, and infrastructure construction in 2026, 2027 or later. Several of those dates are listed as "to be determined."
The site is inside the village's Tax Increment District No. 2. The RFI names pay-as-you-go financing as the main approach and says TIF support is not guaranteed. That makes the district's budget the timeline to watch. The August 18, 2026 Village Board minutes record that the village engineer's updated TID No. 2 financial analysis moved the district's residential development component from 2028 to 2030.
Road work in the district is on a nearer schedule. At that same meeting, the board voted unanimously to have Cedar Corporation design a connector road between Industrial Drive and the future East Garland Street extension, for no more than $128,200. The road serves the planned public safety building and adds a second way into the Lakeview Business Park. The minutes estimate the full project at $865,000. Design was set for this fall, bidding for January, and construction for summer 2027.
This is the second time the site has been on a faster track. In April 2025, WIZM reported a proposal from Country Boom, LLC to buy 85 acres of the County Farm for $2 million. The plan was 60 acres for festival grounds and 25 acres for about 300 homes, starting in 2026 at roughly 20 homes a year. WXOW later reported that the County Executive Committee voted not to sell the farm at that time. The county issued its RFI the following year.
Even once a developer is chosen and the first phase is platted, homes will arrive in stages over 10 to 20 years. Someone buying in the next couple of years will be choosing from homes that already exist.
October sales show where the pressure is
The La Crosse Area REALTORS® Association's November 2026 newsletter breaks down La Crosse County's October 2026 closings and active listings by price band. These are countywide figures, not West Salem alone. West Salem trades inside that county market, though, and the breakdown shows how inventory and sales line up by price.
| Price band, La Crosse County | Sold in October 2026 | Active at end of October 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Under $200,000 | 9 | 13 |
| $200,000 to $299,999 | 36 | 46 |
| $300,000 to $399,999 | 35 | 64 |
| $400,000 to $499,999 | 12 | 31 |
| $500,000 and over | 28 | 66 |
| All prices | 120 | 220 |
The table counts single-family homes, two-family homes and condos. In October 2026, 45 of the 120 sales were under $300,000. At the end of the month, 59 of the 220 active listings were in that range. That works out to about 1.3 months of listings at October's sales pace. Homes priced at $500,000 and over had 66 active listings and 28 sales, which is closer to 2.4 months. October's median residential sale price was $330,000, while the median active single-family listing was $395,000. So the homes for sale skew higher than the homes that actually sell.
Speed tells the same story. Of the 110 residential closings in October 2026, 84 went under contract within 30 days of listing. Only eight took longer than 60 days. Twenty-two of those 110 residential sales were cash deals.
The broader fall numbers say the same thing
The Wisconsin REALTORS® Association's monthly county reports cover the same market over a slightly different window. For August 2026, La Crosse County had a $330,000 median sale price, up 6.3% from August 2025, with 129 sales, 3.7 months of inventory and 70 average days on market. For September 2026, the median was $300,000, down 6.3% from September 2025, on 117 sales, with 3.8 months of inventory and 66 average days on market.
A $30,000 swing in the median from August to September mostly reflects which homes happened to close in each month. The inventory figure moves less. At 3.7 to 3.8 months, the county as a whole is not tight, and October's price bands show that much of that inventory sits at higher prices. A buyer at $280,000 is in a much faster market than the countywide average suggests, while someone shopping at $550,000 can expect more listings and more time to decide.
Closer-in additions in West Salem
Some new housing is being added on a smaller scale. DBS Group's project profile for the Greenfield Addition, developed by P4K Properties, describes a 15-acre plan with 16 single-family sites, five duplex sites and 28 multifamily units in two-story four-, five- and six-plex buildings. The village has also approved a conditional use permit for a 16-unit Riverland Investments apartment building on Crestwood Avenue, according to a Citizen Portal meeting summary.
Both add options. Together they are still dozens of units, set against a County Farm plan sized in the hundreds and a regional forecast of 2,448 new households.
How a buyer under $400,000 should read this
The study behind the County Farm project and October's sales agree on the problem. Homes under $300,000 are the scarcest, and homes up to about $400,000 sell fast. The County Farm is still at the developer-search stage, and the village's district budget has moved its residential component to 2030. For a buyer in that range, the homes on the market now are the ones to plan around.
Waiting for new supply in West Salem is a multi-year bet. Over that time, the 2,448 projected new households will be looking for homes too, and the Lake Neshonoc site will add homes in phases after that.
The existing homes in this price range move within a month. October's numbers show most residential sales going under contract within 30 days, plus a meaningful share of cash buyers. A buyer who has financing settled and knows what they will give up before touring is ready for that pace. Our mortgage calculator and buyer's guide are good places to set that up before a West Salem listing goes live.
Owners in West Salem with a home in the $250,000 to $400,000 range are on the other side of this. They hold the kind of house the county is trying to build more of and won't see much of for several years. Our West Salem neighborhood page tracks the village, and a home valuation shows where a specific house falls in those October price bands.
Plans for the County Farm will move through the county and the village over the next few years, and Favre & Co. follows each step for clients buying and selling in West Salem. If you want to know how your home or your budget fits the price band this plan was built for, ask us, What's My Home Worth?, and we'll show you the actual sales.